Broadway Uprising: 500+ Artists Protest Patti LuPone's Actions Against McDonald And Lewis

James

3 min read

Post on Jun 03, 2025

4.0

Share

Broadway Uprising: 500+ Artists Protest Patti LuPone's Actions Against McDonald and Lewis

The Broadway community is ablaze with controversy following a public rebuke by veteran actress Patti LuPone directed at actors J. Harrison Ghee (who plays Jerry/Daphne in Some Like It Hot) and L Morgan Lee (currently starring in & Juliet). Over 500 artists have signed an open letter condemning LuPone's actions, sparking a significant debate about professionalism, mentorship, and the treatment of young performers in the demanding world of Broadway.

The Incident and its Fallout

The initial incident, which occurred during a post-show Q&A, involved LuPone's criticism of Ghee and Lee's performances. While the exact details remain somewhat murky, with conflicting accounts circulating online, the overall sentiment is that LuPone's critique was perceived as harsh, unprofessional, and publicly humiliating. This sparked immediate backlash on social media, with many actors and industry professionals expressing their support for Ghee and Lee.

The resulting open letter, signed by a broad spectrum of Broadway talent including actors, directors, writers, and designers, accuses LuPone of "bullying," "public shaming," and a general lack of respect for emerging artists. The letter calls for a more supportive and constructive environment within the Broadway community, emphasizing the importance of mentorship over public condemnation. It highlights the already immense pressure faced by young performers and argues that LuPone’s actions exacerbated an already difficult situation.

A Generational Divide?

The controversy has highlighted a potential generational divide within the Broadway community. Some argue that LuPone's approach, though perhaps harsh, reflects a traditional theatrical ethos emphasizing discipline and high standards. Others contend that such methods are outdated and counterproductive, creating a climate of fear and intimidation rather than fostering growth and creativity. This debate has spilled over into broader conversations about workplace culture and the treatment of junior colleagues across various industries.

Key Points of the Controversy:

• Public Shaming: The letter strongly criticizes the public nature of LuPone’s criticism, arguing that such feedback should be delivered privately and constructively.
• Mentorship vs. Bullying: The central point of contention revolves around whether LuPone's actions constituted mentorship or bullying. Many feel the line was crossed.
• The Power Dynamic: The significant power imbalance between an established star like LuPone and newer performers like Ghee and Lee is also a key element of the discussion.
• Impact on Young Performers: The letter emphasizes the potential for such actions to damage the confidence and careers of young and vulnerable artists.

The Future of Broadway Mentorship

This incident raises crucial questions about the future of mentorship within the Broadway community. The open letter serves as a call for change, advocating for a more supportive and inclusive environment where constructive criticism is delivered privately and respectfully. It pushes for better training and resources for emerging artists, helping them navigate the challenges of a highly competitive industry. This isn't just about a single incident; it’s a catalyst for a larger conversation about fostering healthy professional relationships in the arts. The outcome of this controversy will likely shape how mentorship and criticism are approached within the Broadway world for years to come. How will the industry respond to this powerful call for reform? Only time will tell.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts on this controversy? Share your perspective in the comments below. Let's keep the conversation going and work towards a more supportive Broadway community.