West Ham Vs Forest: Player Ratings Reveal Troubled Future For Four

James

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.1

Share

West Ham vs Forest: Player Ratings Reveal Troubled Future for Four

West Ham's narrow 1-0 victory over Nottingham Forest on Saturday offered little in the way of festive cheer for several Hammers players. While the three points were crucial in their fight against relegation, individual performances highlighted potential problem areas for David Moyes and his squad. Post-match player ratings paint a worrying picture for four players in particular, raising questions about their long-term futures at the London Stadium.

A Hard-Fought Win, But Troubling Performances

The match itself was a tense affair, a typical relegation battle where grit and determination outweighed finesse. Michail Antonio's solitary goal proved enough to secure the win, but several players struggled to make a significant impact. While the collective effort secured the victory, individual performances need a closer look, as the squad faces a critical period ahead. The win keeps them in the fight against Premier League relegation, but the performances of some key players are a cause for concern.

The Four Underperforming Players:

Several football analysts and commentators have pointed to four players whose performances warrant serious scrutiny:

• Lucas Paquetá: The Brazilian midfielder, a significant summer signing, continues to underwhelm. His creative spark has been notably absent in recent weeks, and his performance against Forest was no exception. Many pundits awarded him a low rating, questioning whether he’s living up to expectations and his hefty transfer fee. His struggles could have wider implications on the team's overall attacking potency.

• Nayef Aguerd: While Aguerd has shown flashes of brilliance at the back, his inconsistency remains a concern. Against Forest, he was caught out of position on several occasions, highlighting a vulnerability that opposing teams can exploit. Consistent defensive solidity is paramount in a relegation battle, and Aguerd needs to find greater consistency. A look at his overall season stats reveals a mixed bag, needing significant improvement in the second half of the season.

• Aaron Cresswell: The veteran left-back is another player whose performance has dipped. He lacked the attacking impetus that has characterized his previous seasons and looked defensively shaky at times. With the emergence of younger players in the squad, Cresswell’s future at West Ham may be in doubt.

• Gianluca Scamacca: The Italian striker's continued absence through injury is a blow, but even when fit, his impact has been limited. While he undoubtedly possesses talent, his inability to consistently find the net puts pressure on Antonio to deliver week after week. The club may need to consider strengthening their attacking options in the January transfer window, even if it means addressing the future of Scamacca.

Looking Ahead: January Transfer Window and Beyond

The upcoming January transfer window presents a crucial opportunity for West Ham to address these concerns. Strengthening the squad, potentially with replacements or additions in these problem positions, could be vital to securing Premier League survival. The club's decision-making during the transfer window will be key to avoiding a relegation battle.

The manager, David Moyes, will undoubtedly be analyzing these performances closely. The coming weeks and matches will determine whether these four players can rediscover their form and contribute significantly to West Ham's fight for survival. Failure to do so could lead to difficult decisions concerning their futures at the club. The pressure is on, and the next few weeks are crucial.

What are your thoughts on the performances of these West Ham players? Let us know in the comments below!