West Ham Vs Forest: Player Ratings Reveal Four Facing Uncertain Future

James

3 min read

Post on May 19, 2025

4.5

Share

West Ham vs Forest: Player Ratings Reveal Four Facing Uncertain Future

West Ham United's narrow 1-0 victory over Nottingham Forest left much to be debated, but post-match player ratings have highlighted four players whose futures at the London Stadium appear increasingly uncertain. The win, secured by a solitary Bowen goal, offered little in the way of convincing performance, leaving manager David Moyes with some serious questions to answer heading into the crucial final stretch of the Premier League season.

The Hammers' struggle for consistency this season has been well-documented, and this match did little to alleviate those concerns. While the three points were vital in the fight against relegation, the underlying performance suggests a squad in need of a significant overhaul during the summer transfer window. Let's delve into the individual performances and the players whose positions seem most precarious.

The Underperformers: A Look at the Ratings

Several sources, including The Athletic and Football London, published post-match player ratings that painted a bleak picture for certain players. While individual ratings varied slightly across publications, a clear consensus emerged regarding four players who significantly underwhelmed:

• Said Benrahma: Consistently criticised for inconsistency this season, Benrahma's performance against Forest was deemed underwhelming by most analysts. His lack of end product and occasional defensive lapses are becoming a major concern for Moyes. His average rating across various sources hovered around a 5.5/10, highlighting his struggle to make a significant impact.

• Lucas Paquetá: The Brazilian midfielder, a significant investment last summer, continues to fail to justify his price tag. His creative spark has been absent in several recent matches, and against Forest, he seemed to struggle to influence the game effectively. Ratings around the 6/10 mark suggest a player failing to meet expectations.

• Nayef Aguerd: The Moroccan centre-back, while showing flashes of brilliance at times, has been plagued by inconsistency. His defensive positioning and occasional lapses in concentration remain a worry. A rating in the low 6s suggests a player needing to improve his consistency to solidify his place in the starting XI.

• Gianluca Scamacca: The Italian striker's struggles continued against Forest. Despite having opportunities, he failed to convert and his overall contribution to the team was minimal. A sub-par performance with ratings around 5.8/10 raises serious questions about his future at the club, especially with the club's need for a reliable goalscorer.

What the Future Holds: Potential Departures and Squad Overhaul

The performances of these four players raise significant questions about their long-term futures at West Ham. With the club battling relegation, and needing a significant uplift in performance, a summer clear-out seems increasingly likely. These players could be deemed surplus to requirements as Moyes looks to rebuild his squad and inject some much-needed dynamism and consistency into the team.

The upcoming transfer window will be critical for West Ham. The club needs to make strategic signings to address the weaknesses exposed throughout the season. The potential departures of these four players could free up significant funds and squad space, allowing Moyes to bring in players who can contribute meaningfully to the team's success.

What are your thoughts on the performances of these players? Do you agree with the assessment of their uncertain futures? Share your opinions in the comments below!