Should Cody Rhodes Return To WWE SmackDown? A Preview Analysis

James

3 min read

Post on May 25, 2025

4.6

Share

Should Cody Rhodes Return to WWE SmackDown? A Preview Analysis

The wrestling world is buzzing. After a stunning loss at WrestleMania 39, the question on everyone's lips is: where does Cody Rhodes go from here? Many fans are clamoring for a return to the blue brand, WWE SmackDown. But is it the right move for "The American Nightmare"? Let's delve into a preview analysis, weighing the pros and cons of a potential SmackDown homecoming.

The Allure of SmackDown:

A move to SmackDown offers several compelling advantages for Cody Rhodes. Firstly, the brand currently boasts a less crowded main event scene than Raw. This would immediately elevate Rhodes' status, positioning him as a top contender. He could potentially feud with established stars like Roman Reigns (should Reigns eventually transition to SmackDown), Gunther, or even a surprising opponent like LA Knight. The opportunity to reinvent himself on a different platform, away from the shadow of his WrestleMania defeat, is significant.

Furthermore, SmackDown's distinct style and atmosphere could revitalize Rhodes' character. The show often leans towards a more gritty, underdog narrative, which could perfectly complement Rhodes' journey. This shift in environment could help him regain momentum and reconnect with a broader audience.

The Challenges of a SmackDown Return:

Despite the enticing possibilities, a return to SmackDown isn't without its challenges. Firstly, a potential feud with Roman Reigns is highly dependent on Reigns’ own future plans. If Reigns remains on Raw, the inter-brand dynamics could complicate things. Secondly, the success of any storyline hinges on creative booking. WWE's writing team needs to craft compelling narratives to justify Rhodes' presence and prevent him from becoming lost in the shuffle.

Another crucial aspect is the potential audience reaction. While a significant portion of the fanbase would welcome his return, some might view it as a step back, given his recent near-main event status. Managing expectations and delivering on the hype will be vital for his sustained success.

Alternative Scenarios: Beyond SmackDown

Before jumping to conclusions, it's crucial to consider other potential avenues for Cody Rhodes. A prolonged absence to heal from injury and re-evaluate his character arc could be beneficial. Returning with a revamped look, persona, or even a new faction could generate massive excitement. Alternatively, a continued presence on Raw, but in a different role (perhaps mentoring younger talent), could prove equally effective.

Conclusion: A Calculated Risk

Ultimately, a return to WWE SmackDown for Cody Rhodes presents both significant opportunities and considerable challenges. The success of such a move would depend heavily on creative booking and audience reception. While the potential for a compelling storyline is undeniable, WWE must carefully consider how to integrate him effectively into the SmackDown landscape. Only time will tell if this is the right path for "The American Nightmare" to reclaim his place among wrestling's elite. What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments below!

Keywords: Cody Rhodes, WWE SmackDown, WWE Raw, WrestleMania 39, Roman Reigns, Gunther, LA Knight, wrestling, professional wrestling, WWE, wrestling news, Cody Rhodes return, WWE storylines.