Public Service Commission And Climate Change: A Data-Driven Analysis By Environmental Journalists

James

3 min read

Post on May 26, 2025

4.2

Share

Public Service Commissions and Climate Change: A Data-Driven Analysis

The critical role of Public Service Commissions (PSCs) in addressing climate change is often overlooked, yet their influence on energy policy and infrastructure development is immense. This data-driven analysis, compiled by environmental journalists, reveals the complex interplay between PSC decisions and the urgent need for climate action. We examine how these commissions, responsible for regulating utilities and ensuring reliable service, are – or are not – incorporating climate considerations into their decision-making processes.

The Power of the PSC: Shaping Energy Futures

Public Service Commissions wield significant power in shaping the energy landscape. Their mandates typically include:

• Regulating utility rates: PSCs determine the prices consumers pay for electricity, gas, and water, indirectly influencing the demand for renewable energy sources. High rates for fossil fuels can incentivize consumers and businesses to switch to cleaner alternatives.
• Approving infrastructure projects: From new power plants to transmission lines, PSCs play a crucial role in determining which energy projects get built. This authority provides a powerful lever for advancing renewable energy and phasing out carbon-intensive infrastructure.
• Setting energy efficiency standards: PSCs often establish energy efficiency targets for utilities, encouraging them to invest in technologies and programs that reduce energy consumption. This contributes significantly to reducing overall carbon emissions.

However, the extent to which PSCs actively consider climate change in their decision-making varies significantly across states and jurisdictions.

A Patchwork of Approaches: Data Reveals Disparities

Our analysis of publicly available data from across the United States reveals a fragmented approach to climate change integration within PSCs. Some commissions have proactively incorporated climate goals into their regulatory frameworks, while others lag behind, prioritizing short-term economic concerns over long-term environmental sustainability. Key disparities include:

• Integration of climate goals into ratemaking: While some PSCs explicitly consider the carbon footprint of energy sources when setting rates, others primarily focus on cost-effectiveness, potentially hindering the transition to renewables.
• Stringency of renewable portfolio standards (RPS): The ambition of RPS mandates, which dictate the percentage of electricity that must come from renewable sources, varies widely, reflecting differing levels of commitment to climate action.
• Approvals for fossil fuel infrastructure projects: Some PSCs readily approve new fossil fuel projects, despite their climate implications, while others are more cautious, demanding stricter environmental reviews and mitigation strategies.

The Path Forward: Recommendations for Climate-Conscious Regulation

The data clearly indicates a need for greater alignment between PSC decisions and climate goals. To accelerate the transition to a clean energy future, we recommend:

• Strengthening climate mandates for PSCs: Legislatures should explicitly require PSCs to consider climate change impacts in all their decisions, setting clear targets for emissions reductions.
• Investing in data and expertise: PSCs need access to high-quality data and expert advice on climate science and clean energy technologies to inform their regulatory decisions.
• Promoting transparency and public participation: Openness and public engagement are crucial to ensure that PSC decisions reflect the interests of all stakeholders and contribute to a just and equitable transition.
• Encouraging collaboration and information sharing: Best practices and lessons learned should be shared among PSCs to improve efficiency and effectiveness in climate action.

Conclusion:

Public Service Commissions play a pivotal role in shaping our energy future and mitigating climate change. By incorporating climate considerations into their regulatory frameworks, these commissions can significantly accelerate the transition to a cleaner, more sustainable energy system. Further research and transparent data sharing are essential to drive effective change and ensure that PSCs effectively serve the public interest in the face of the climate crisis. We urge readers to contact their state's Public Service Commission to learn more about their climate policies and encourage proactive engagement in promoting sustainable energy solutions.