Is Platonic Season Two Worth Watching? A Critical Review

James

3 min read

Post on Aug 07, 2025

4.5

Share

Is Platonic Season Two Worth Watching? A Critical Review

Are you wondering if Platonic's second season lives up to the hype? We delve into the critical reviews and viewer reactions to give you the definitive answer.

The first season of Apple TV+'s Platonic charmed audiences with its witty writing and relatable portrayal of a rekindled friendship between estranged childhood best friends, Sylvia and Will. But did season two maintain that momentum, or did it fall flat? Let's unpack the critical reception and viewer opinions to determine if Platonic season two is worth adding to your watchlist.

A Refreshing Take on Adult Friendship, Initially

Season one successfully captured the complexities of adult relationships, highlighting the messy, hilarious, and often frustrating dynamics of close friendships. The chemistry between Rose Byrne (Sylvia) and Seth Rogen (Will) was undeniable, carrying the show through its sometimes uneven pacing. The exploration of long-term friendships, mid-life crises, and the challenges of maintaining healthy relationships resonated deeply with viewers. Many praised the show's honest depiction of adult friendships, a refreshing change from the often idealized portrayals in other comedies.

Season Two: A Mixed Bag of Reviews

The critical response to Platonic season two has been more divided than its predecessor. While some critics lauded the continued strong performances of Byrne and Rogen, many felt the season lacked the sharp wit and comedic timing of the first. Several reviewers noted a shift in tone, with some storylines feeling less grounded and more reliant on broad comedic tropes.

• The Verdict on the Humor: While season one balanced heartwarming moments with laugh-out-loud humor, season two leaned more heavily into the latter, sometimes at the expense of emotional depth. Some viewers felt the humor became predictable and less sophisticated.

• Character Development (or Lack Thereof): A common complaint was the perceived lack of significant character development. While the characters faced new challenges, the overall arc felt less transformative than in season one. Several critics felt the show failed to fully explore the emotional consequences of certain plot points.

• Pacing Issues: The pacing of season two also received mixed reviews, with some viewers feeling the season dragged in places. Others felt the shorter episode count allowed for a more concise and impactful narrative.

Is it Worth Your Time?

Ultimately, whether or not Platonic season two is worth watching depends on your expectations and what you enjoyed about the first season. If you loved the sharp wit and relatable portrayal of adult friendship in season one, you might find yourself slightly disappointed. However, if you're a fan of Byrne and Rogen's chemistry and enjoy lighter, more comedic fare, you'll likely still find enjoyment in season two.

Here's a quick breakdown:

• For fans of season one: Approach with cautious optimism. It’s not a drastic departure, but it’s a noticeable shift in tone and focus.
• For new viewers: Start with season one. Season two works better with the context established in the first installment.

In conclusion: Platonic season two offers more of the same, but with a less consistent execution. While it doesn't reach the heights of season one, it's not necessarily a bad watch. The performances remain strong, and there are moments of genuine humor and heartfelt connection. But manage your expectations – this season is more of a continuation than a significant evolution.

What are your thoughts on Platonic Season Two? Share your opinions in the comments below!