Five Years Post-George Floyd: Measuring Systemic Change In American Policing

James

3 min read

Post on May 26, 2025

4.9

Share

Five Years Post-George Floyd: Measuring Systemic Change in American Policing

Five years have passed since the murder of George Floyd ignited a global reckoning on racial injustice and police brutality. The protests that followed demanded sweeping reforms in American policing, promising a future where accountability and equity were paramount. But have these promises materialized? Measuring systemic change in policing is a complex undertaking, requiring a nuanced examination of policies, practices, and outcomes. This article delves into the progress (or lack thereof) made since 2020, exploring key areas of reform and the challenges that remain.

The Landscape of Police Reform: A Mixed Bag

The aftermath of Floyd's death saw a surge in legislative activity at both the state and federal levels. Many states passed laws aimed at increasing police accountability, including:

• Increased Transparency: Mandates for the release of police body camera footage and disciplinary records are becoming more common, although access varies significantly by jurisdiction. [Link to relevant ACLU report on police transparency]
• Changes in Use of Force Policies: Some departments have adopted reforms to their use of force policies, emphasizing de-escalation techniques and restricting the use of chokeholds and no-knock warrants. [Link to relevant DOJ report on use-of-force policies]
• Independent Investigations: A growing number of jurisdictions are establishing independent civilian review boards or other mechanisms to investigate police misconduct. [Link to example of a city with a successful civilian review board]
• Enhanced Training: Increased emphasis on implicit bias training and de-escalation tactics in police academies has been observed. However, the effectiveness of these training programs remains a subject of ongoing debate. [Link to research on effectiveness of implicit bias training]

However, the implementation and enforcement of these reforms have been uneven. Many departments have resisted meaningful change, citing resource constraints or concerns about officer morale. Furthermore, the effectiveness of these reforms in meaningfully altering police behavior and reducing instances of police brutality remains questionable.

Measuring the Impact: Data and Challenges

Quantifying the impact of police reforms is difficult due to several factors:

• Data Collection Inconsistencies: Data on police misconduct and use of force varies widely across jurisdictions, hindering meaningful comparisons and national-level analysis. The lack of standardized data collection practices makes it challenging to track trends and assess the effectiveness of reforms.
• Underreporting of Incidents: Many instances of police misconduct go unreported, especially those involving communities of color who may distrust the system. This underreporting creates an incomplete picture of the problem.
• Long-Term Impact: Measuring the long-term impact of reforms requires sustained data collection and analysis over several years. It is too early to definitively assess the lasting effects of the reforms implemented since 2020.

The Road Ahead: Addressing Systemic Issues

Despite the challenges, there are reasons for cautious optimism. The increased public awareness of police brutality and the demand for accountability have created a momentum for change. However, true systemic change requires:

• Comprehensive Data Collection and Analysis: Standardized data collection across jurisdictions is crucial for accurate assessment of the effectiveness of reforms.
• Increased Funding for Community-Based Initiatives: Investing in community-based programs that address the root causes of crime and violence is essential for a holistic approach to public safety.
• Accountability and Transparency: Holding police officers accountable for misconduct and ensuring transparency in police operations are critical to building trust between law enforcement and the communities they serve.
• Continued Public Pressure: Sustained public engagement and advocacy remain essential to ensuring that police reform efforts are not stalled or diluted.

The five years since George Floyd's murder have been a period of both progress and persistent challenges. While some reforms have been implemented, the journey towards truly equitable and accountable policing is far from over. It requires sustained effort, commitment, and a commitment to data-driven solutions to address systemic issues that continue to plague American law enforcement. The fight for justice continues.