Donald Trump's Use Of Pope Leo XIII: A Rhetorical Strategy

James

3 min read

Post on May 11, 2025

4.2

Share

Donald Trump's Use of Pope Leo XIII: A Rhetorical Strategy of Populist Appeal

Donald Trump's presidency was marked by a distinctive rhetorical style, often employing historical figures and religious references to bolster his arguments and connect with his base. One less-discussed, yet intriguing, example is his strategic, albeit sometimes inaccurate, invocation of Pope Leo XIII. This article explores how Trump utilized the pontiff's legacy, particularly his encyclical Rerum Novarum, as a rhetorical tool to advance his populist agenda.

Leo XIII and Rerum Novarum: A Foundation for Social Conservatism

Pope Leo XIII's 1891 encyclical, Rerum Novarum, remains a cornerstone of Catholic social teaching. It addressed the social and economic injustices of the Industrial Revolution, advocating for the rights of workers while simultaneously criticizing socialism and unrestrained capitalism. The encyclical champions the dignity of the human person, the importance of private property, and the role of the state in promoting the common good. This complex and nuanced document has been interpreted in various ways throughout history, lending itself to selective appropriation.

Trump's Selective Interpretation and Rhetorical Use

Trump, known for his populist appeal, selectively invoked elements of Rerum Novarum to support his own political positions. While he rarely quoted the encyclical directly, his rhetoric often echoed its themes, particularly those concerning the perceived failures of globalization and the need to protect national interests. For example, Trump’s emphasis on protecting American jobs and industries could be seen as aligning with Leo XIII's concern for the well-being of workers. However, this alignment is far from complete.

The Gaps and Contradictions:

It’s crucial to note the significant discrepancies between Trump's policies and the actual teachings of Leo XIII. Rerum Novarum emphasizes social justice, advocating for fair wages, safe working conditions, and the right to organize. While Trump often championed the working class rhetorically, his actual policies, such as tax cuts that primarily benefited the wealthy, often contradicted this purported alignment. Furthermore, Leo XIII's emphasis on the importance of the common good and social responsibility sits uneasily with Trump's often individualistic and protectionist approach.

A Tool for Populist Mobilization:

Despite these inconsistencies, Trump's invocation of Leo XIII served a clear rhetorical purpose: to garner support from socially conservative and religiously inclined voters. By associating himself, however loosely, with a respected figure in Catholic history, Trump sought to lend legitimacy to his policies and appeal to a specific demographic. This strategy, while potentially misleading, proved effective in mobilizing a significant portion of his electorate.

The Impact and Legacy:

The use of Pope Leo XIII and Rerum Novarum by Donald Trump highlights the complex ways in which historical figures and religious texts can be strategically employed in political discourse. It demonstrates the potential for selective interpretation and the power of symbolic association in shaping public opinion. Understanding this rhetorical strategy provides valuable insight into the methods used to mobilize political support and the importance of critically analyzing political rhetoric. Further research is needed to explore the effectiveness of this particular tactic and its impact on the broader political landscape.

Keywords: Donald Trump, Pope Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum, Catholic Social Teaching, Populism, Rhetorical Strategy, Political Rhetoric, Presidential Rhetoric, Social Justice, American Politics.