Donald Trump's Use Of Pope Leo XIII: A Rhetorical Analysis

James

3 min read

Post on May 10, 2025

4.4

Share

Donald Trump's Use of Pope Leo XIII: A Rhetorical Analysis

Donald Trump's presidency was marked by a distinctive rhetorical style, often employing historical figures and religious imagery to bolster his arguments. One notable example involves his invocation of Pope Leo XIII, a figure rarely referenced in contemporary American political discourse. This article will delve into a rhetorical analysis of Trump's use of Leo XIII, examining the strategies employed and their impact on his audience.

The Context: Leo XIII and the Rerum Novarum

Pope Leo XIII's encyclical Rerum Novarum (1891) is central to understanding Trump's references. This document addressed the social and economic issues arising from the Industrial Revolution, advocating for the rights of workers while upholding the importance of private property. While seemingly disparate from Trump's populist message, certain aspects resonated with his rhetoric. Trump often emphasized themes of economic nationalism, advocating for American workers and businesses against perceived foreign competition. By associating himself with Rerum Novarum, albeit selectively, Trump aimed to lend an air of moral authority to his economic policies.

Rhetorical Strategies Employed:

Trump's use of Leo XIII wasn't explicitly stated as an endorsement of the entire encyclical. Instead, it was a strategic deployment of selected themes:

• Selective Quotation and Interpretation: Trump rarely quoted Rerum Novarum directly. Instead, he evoked the spirit of the encyclical, focusing on aspects supporting his nationalist agenda. This allowed for flexibility in interpretation, avoiding direct engagement with potentially contradictory elements of Leo XIII's social teaching.

• Appeal to Authority: Invoking a respected religious figure like Pope Leo XIII provided a veneer of legitimacy to Trump's economic proposals. This appeal to authority sought to bypass intellectual debate and sway audiences based on perceived credibility.

• Creation of an Us vs. Them Narrative: Trump's use of Leo XIII often implicitly positioned him as a defender of the American worker against globalist forces, mirroring some of the concerns addressed in Rerum Novarum. This strengthened his populist appeal by framing the issue as a moral struggle.

Analyzing the Impact:

The impact of Trump's strategic use of Pope Leo XIII is multifaceted:

• Mobilization of Conservative Catholic Voters: By invoking a prominent figure within the Catholic tradition, Trump sought to solidify his support among conservative Catholic voters, a crucial demographic in several key states.

• Differentiation from Traditional Republicanism: While some elements of Trump's economic policy aligned with aspects of Rerum Novarum, his approach differed significantly from traditional Republican orthodoxy. This rhetorical strategy allowed him to present himself as an innovator while maintaining a certain degree of religious appeal.

• Limited Understanding of the Encyclical's Nuances: Critics argue that Trump's selective use of Rerum Novarum lacked a deep understanding of its complex social and economic arguments. This superficial engagement risked misrepresenting the Pope's intentions and alienating those familiar with the encyclical's full context.

Conclusion:

Donald Trump's invocation of Pope Leo XIII exemplifies a calculated rhetorical strategy. By selectively employing themes from Rerum Novarum, he aimed to bolster his populist economic message, appealing to specific demographics and lending a sense of moral authority to his policies. However, a deeper analysis reveals a strategic simplification of a complex historical and theological text, raising questions about the ethical implications of such selective engagement. Further research could explore the specific instances where Trump referenced Leo XIII and analyze the immediate and long-term effects on his political standing. Understanding this rhetorical approach offers valuable insights into the communication strategies employed by populist leaders in the modern political landscape.