Can Manchester United Solve Their Goalkeeping Problems? Early Season Struggles

James

3 min read

Post on Aug 18, 2025

4.0

Share

Can Manchester United Solve Their Goalkeeping Problems? Early Season Struggles Raise Concerns

Manchester United's early season form has been a rollercoaster, but one persistent issue overshadows even their inconsistent attacking play: the goalkeeping conundrum. While the Red Devils boast a star-studded squad capable of challenging for the Premier League title, their vulnerability between the posts is a significant concern, raising serious questions about their ability to compete at the highest level. Can Erik ten Hag and his team find a solution before it's too late?

The departure of David de Gea, a long-serving figure at Old Trafford, marked the end of an era. While undeniably a talented shot-stopper, De Gea’s distribution and modern goalkeeping skills were often criticized. His replacement, André Onana, arrived with a reputation for his impressive ball-playing abilities, a key component of ten Hag's tactical philosophy. However, the early season performances haven't been entirely convincing.

<h3>Onana's Uncertain Start: A Mixed Bag</h3>

Onana has undoubtedly brought a new dimension to United's game. His ability to initiate attacks from the back, playing out from the pressure, is a refreshing change. He’s comfortable with the ball at his feet and displays a confidence rarely seen from United goalkeepers in recent years. However, this newfound adventurousness has also led to mistakes. A few high-profile errors have highlighted a potential vulnerability – a willingness to take risks that haven't always paid off.

• Strengths: Excellent distribution, comfortable with the ball at his feet, commanding presence in the box.
• Weaknesses: Prone to occasional errors in judgment, decision-making under pressure needs improvement.

This isn't necessarily a sign of failure, but rather a period of adaptation. Every goalkeeper experiences a settling-in period, especially when transitioning to a new league and a different playing style. The question remains: can Onana refine his decision-making and reduce these errors while maintaining his positive contribution to United's build-up play?

<h3>The Backup Situation: A Potential Weakness?</h3>

Beyond Onana, the backup goalkeeper situation also warrants examination. The reliability of the second-choice keeper is crucial, especially considering the demanding schedule of Premier League and European football. Any injury or loss of form to Onana could expose a significant weakness if the backup isn't up to scratch. This is an area where Manchester United needs depth and quality to ensure consistent performance.

<h3>Can Manchester United Overcome This Challenge?</h3>

The answer is likely yes, but it requires patience and careful management. Ten Hag's tactical approach relies heavily on Onana's ability to play out from the back, meaning a simple swap wouldn't necessarily solve the problem. Instead, a focus on refining Onana’s decision-making, coupled with providing him with the necessary support and protection from the defense, is crucial. Furthermore, strengthening the backup goalkeeper position should be a priority to ensure resilience throughout the season.

Ultimately, Manchester United's success this season will depend, in part, on resolving this goalkeeping conundrum. While the early signs haven't been entirely positive, there's still ample time for Onana to adjust and for the team to solidify their defensive structure. The coming weeks and months will be critical in determining whether this early-season wobble can be transformed into a season of success. Are you confident Manchester United can overcome this challenge? Let us know in the comments below!