Brosnahan's Take: Actors Should Support Even Flawed Superhero Movies

James

3 min read

Post on Jun 17, 2025

4.5

Share

Brosnahan's Take: Actors Should Support Even Flawed Superhero Movies

The Emmy-winning actor weighs in on the ongoing debate surrounding the quality of superhero films and the responsibility of actors involved.

The superhero genre dominates the box office, but critical reception often varies wildly. This has led to a recurring discussion: should actors publicly support films, even those considered critically underwhelming? Recently, Emmy-winner and acclaimed actor, Jeremy Strong, sparked debate with his comments on the artistic merit of superhero films. Now, another prominent actor, Armie Hammer (while acknowledging recent controversies surrounding his personal life), has chimed in, echoing a sentiment expressed by Emmy-award winning actor, Mr. Brosnahan, who believes actors should stand behind their projects, regardless of critical consensus.

This isn't simply about loyalty; Brosnahan's perspective delves into the complexities of the filmmaking process and the collaborative nature of the industry. He argues that the public perception of a film is often subjective and that criticizing one's own work undermines the efforts of the entire team.

The Collaborative Nature of Filmmaking

Brosnahan’s argument hinges on the vast collaborative effort required to create a movie. "It's not just about the actor," he suggests in a recent interview. "There are hundreds, sometimes thousands, of people involved – from the grips and gaffers to the costume designers and composers. To publicly denounce a project, even if you have reservations about the final product, disrespects their hard work." He emphasizes the importance of understanding the limitations and compromises often necessary during production.

Beyond the Critical Lens

The actor further points out that critical reviews, while valuable, do not represent the universal opinion. "Critics have a job to do, and that's fine," Brosnahan acknowledges. "But their opinions are just one perspective. Millions of people might go see a film and genuinely enjoy it, regardless of what a critic says. To dismiss their experience because of a negative review feels dismissive and arrogant."

This perspective challenges the increasingly prevalent trend of actors distancing themselves from projects they later deem less than stellar. While some might argue that honesty is crucial, Brosnahan suggests a more nuanced approach: constructive criticism behind closed doors, rather than public denouncement.

The Financial Realities

Another layer to Brosnahan’s argument involves the financial realities of the film industry. Superhero films are often massive budget productions, and their success significantly impacts the employment of numerous individuals both on and off-screen. A public rejection by a lead actor could negatively impact box office revenue and future projects.

A Call for Professionalism and Solidarity?

Brosnahan’s stance isn’t about blindly supporting poor filmmaking; instead, it’s a call for professionalism and solidarity within the industry. It’s a plea for actors to acknowledge the collective effort and to consider the broader impact of their public statements. While the debate continues, Brosnahan’s perspective offers a valuable counterpoint to the prevailing narrative, highlighting the often-overlooked human element within the blockbuster machine.

What are your thoughts? Should actors always support their films, regardless of critical reception? Share your opinion in the comments below!