Assessing Trump's Foreign Policy: Successes And Failures In Peacebuilding

James

3 min read

Post on Jun 24, 2025

4.9

Share

Assessing Trump's Foreign Policy: Successes and Failures in Peacebuilding

Donald Trump's presidency (2017-2021) marked a significant departure from traditional US foreign policy, particularly in its approach to peacebuilding. While often characterized by a "America First" approach, his administration's actions yielded a mixed bag of successes and failures in various global hotspots. Analyzing these outcomes requires a nuanced understanding of his administration's strategies and their long-term implications.

Key Approaches to Peacebuilding Under Trump:

Trump's foreign policy eschewed multilateralism in favor of bilateral deals and transactional diplomacy. This approach significantly impacted peacebuilding efforts, sometimes yielding positive results, but often creating new challenges. Key characteristics included:

• Emphasis on Bilateral Deals: Rather than relying on international organizations, the Trump administration prioritized direct negotiations with individual countries. This was evident in the Abraham Accords, a significant diplomatic achievement.
• Withdrawal from International Agreements: The withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal and the Paris Agreement on climate change raised concerns about US commitment to international cooperation, potentially undermining peacebuilding initiatives dependent on global consensus.
• Increased Military Spending and Interventionism: Despite rhetoric about reducing US involvement in foreign conflicts, the Trump administration authorized military actions in several regions, impacting existing peace processes and potentially fueling instability.

Successes in Peacebuilding:

• The Abraham Accords: Arguably the most significant foreign policy achievement of the Trump administration, the Abraham Accords normalized relations between Israel and several Arab nations, including the UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, and Sudan. This breakthrough represented a significant step towards regional stability and offered a potential model for future peace negotiations. [Link to relevant State Department documentation on the Abraham Accords]
• Increased Pressure on Taliban (Initially): The early Trump administration pursued a strategy of increased pressure on the Taliban in Afghanistan, leading to negotiations that initially appeared promising. While the ultimate outcome remains contested, this period saw a temporary reduction in violence in some areas.

Failures in Peacebuilding:

• Withdrawal from the Iran Nuclear Deal: The Trump administration's withdrawal from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) undermined international efforts to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons and increased regional tensions, jeopardizing existing peacebuilding efforts in the Middle East. [Link to relevant news articles on the impact of the JCPOA withdrawal]
• Afghanistan Withdrawal: The chaotic withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan in 2021 led to the rapid collapse of the Afghan government and the resurgence of the Taliban, resulting in a humanitarian crisis and undermining years of peacebuilding efforts. [Link to reputable analysis of the Afghanistan withdrawal]
• Strained Relations with Allies: Trump's confrontational approach to international relations damaged trust with key allies, impacting collaborative peacebuilding initiatives and weakening multilateral efforts to address global conflicts. This hampered efforts to coordinate responses to crises and reduce tensions in various regions.

Long-Term Implications:

Trump's foreign policy legacy on peacebuilding remains a subject of ongoing debate. While the Abraham Accords stand as a notable achievement, the consequences of his administration's other actions, particularly the Afghanistan withdrawal and the withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal, are still unfolding. The long-term impact on US credibility as a partner in peacebuilding initiatives and the stability of several regions remains to be seen.

Conclusion:

Assessing Trump's impact on peacebuilding requires considering both the positive and negative consequences of his policies. The successes, like the Abraham Accords, showcase the potential for transactional diplomacy, while the failures highlight the risks associated with unilateralism and a disregard for multilateral cooperation. A thorough analysis requires examining both the immediate outcomes and the longer-term implications for global stability and international relations. Further research and analysis are crucial to fully understand the lasting effects of his administration’s actions on the international landscape.