Alison Brie On "Scream": The Core Four Must Die For The Franchise To Thrive

James

3 min read

Post on Aug 11, 2025

4.1

Share

Alison Brie on "Scream": The Core Four Must Die for the Franchise to Thrive

The enduring legacy of the Scream franchise hinges on its ability to reinvent itself while staying true to its meta-horror roots. With the recent release of Scream VI, conversations around the future of the series are swirling, and one particularly bold opinion comes from Alison Brie, whose performance as Detective Bailey in the latest installment has garnered significant praise. Brie believes the franchise needs a drastic shake-up to maintain its relevance and chilling edge: the core four – Sam, Tara, Mindy, and Chad – must die.

This controversial statement isn't just a casual remark; Brie argues it's a necessary sacrifice for the Scream franchise to truly evolve. Her reasoning is rooted in the franchise's history, a history built on subverting horror tropes and shocking audiences with unexpected deaths.

Why Killing the Core Four is Crucial for Scream's Future

The original Scream trilogy successfully established a formula: introducing a group of relatable characters, only to systematically eliminate them in increasingly gruesome ways. This approach kept audiences on the edge of their seats, never knowing who would survive the next encounter with Ghostface. While Scream (2022) and Scream VI successfully resurrected the franchise, the survival of the core four, despite facing numerous threats, feels somewhat at odds with this established pattern.

Brie argues that keeping these characters alive creates a sense of predictability. Audiences now expect them to survive, diminishing the impact of the suspense and the overall thrill of the killer's game. By killing off the core four, the franchise would:

• Re-establish the high stakes: The death of beloved characters is a key element of the Scream formula. The deaths of Sidney Prescott's friends in the original films, for example, were pivotal moments.
• Open up narrative possibilities: Eliminating the core four would free up the storytelling, allowing for fresh perspectives and new character dynamics in future installments.
• Force creative risks: The writers would be forced to develop innovative ways to maintain suspense and tension, without relying on the familiar safety net of established characters.
• Maintain the franchise's unpredictability: Killing off main characters is what made Scream stand out from other slasher films. This unpredictable element is vital for the franchise's long-term survival.

The Legacy of Ghostface and the Need for Change

Ghostface's reign of terror relies on the element of surprise. The killer's identity is always a key part of the mystery and the shock factor. The continued survival of the core four risks making future installments feel repetitive and predictable, ultimately undermining the very essence of what makes Scream so compelling. As Brie subtly hints, the franchise needs to embrace the unexpected and accept that some beloved characters need to be sacrificed for the greater good of the franchise’s overall longevity and critical acclaim.

What Lies Ahead for the Scream Franchise?

Whether the producers and writers of the Scream franchise will heed Alison Brie's advice remains to be seen. However, her comments spark a valuable conversation about the challenges of maintaining a long-running horror franchise. The franchise's future will depend on its ability to adapt and embrace change while honoring its roots. Perhaps, the next Ghostface will have a particularly bloody and definitive end for Sam, Tara, Mindy, and Chad. Only time will tell.

What are your thoughts? Should the core four die to keep the Scream franchise alive and terrifying? Share your opinions in the comments below!